The household of a safety guard killed by an Army Ranger in downtown Tacoma has settled a lawsuit towards two companies alleged to have over-served alcohol to the soldier earlier than the deadly assault in 2021.
Denise Smith, 41, was crushed to dying on the Frank Russell Constructing, the place she solely not too long ago had begun working. Smith had tried to stop Spc. Patrick Philip Byrne from coming into on July 18, 2021, The News Tribune beforehand reported. Byrne, 26 on the time of the assault, pleaded responsible to first-degree homicide and was later sentenced to twenty years in jail in Might 2024.
Byrne, who was stationed at Joint Base Lewis-McChord, had been out ingesting with associates from JBLM at two adjoining bar/eating places on Pacific Avenue – The Discussion board and The Workplace – previous to the assault, in keeping with the wrongful-death lawsuit filed in July 2024. The grievance, lodged by Smith’s father and 4 siblings in Pierce County Superior Court docket, alleged the companies continued to serve drinks to Byrne when he was clearly intoxicated.
The lawsuit was dismissed this month after the household settled with the 2 institutions, avoiding a trial most not too long ago scheduled for Might 2026, in keeping with courtroom filings on Sept. 11 and Sept. 12.
Legal professional Brett Purtzer, who represented the plaintiffs, confirmed each settlements Wednesday however stated the phrases had been confidential, stopping him from talking in any element in regards to the decision.
“We decided that this was one of the simplest ways to go,” Purtzer stated, including that he was “blissful for the household.”
An lawyer representing The Workplace declined to touch upon the matter. A message left with representatives for The Discussion board was not instantly returned.
In courtroom filings final 12 months, legal professionals for each companies denied allegations raised within the grievance and wrote that Byrne, who was not named as a defendant within the lawsuit, was at fault for any civil damages.
Whereas at The Workplace, Byrne was concerned in a bodily altercation the place he was punched within the head and knocked to the concrete, in keeping with courtroom information within the prison case. Minutes after he regained consciousness, Byrne tried to enter the constructing the place Smith labored at 909 A. St.
Byrne was captured on surveillance video dragging Smith by her hair, repeatedly punching her, utilizing her keys to stab her within the face and apparently trying to gouge her eyes out, courtroom information stated. He then choked her till she went limp and continued to choke her for a minute or two afterward.
Byrne stated he couldn’t bear in mind any particulars from that night time. His authorized protection cited proof he had suffered an damage through the bar struggle that affected the realm of the mind that controls morality and judgment. Earlier than his sentencing, Pierce County Superior Court docket Choose Stanley Rumbaugh positioned accountability on Byrne.
Whereas the Ranger may need misplaced some capability through the crime, it was a option to get intoxicated to the purpose of changing into belligerent and uncontrollable in a public place, Rumbaugh stated. Byrne beforehand suffered head accidents within the army and from automobile wrecks, however he selected to make these issues worse by ingesting alcohol in extra, in keeping with the decide, who known as Byrne’s act “unspeakably merciless.”
The lawsuit, citing witnesses, alleged that Byrne had one to a few drinks over the course of an hour to 90 minutes whereas at The Discussion board after which, in keeping with a buddy, roughly eight combined drinks or beers at The Workplace the place he stayed for a number of hours. Witnesses had described Byrne as “fairly drunk,” “very drunk,” “positively intoxicated,” clearly intoxicated” and “in a mode of blackout,” the go well with stated.
Some drinks, in keeping with the go well with, had been bought by Byrne’s associates.
© 2025 The Peninsula Gateway (Gig Harbor, Wash.).
Go to www.thenewstribune.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.
Story Continues
© Copyright 2025 The Peninsula Gateway (Gig Harbor, Wash.). All rights reserved. This materials will not be printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
